Lyle Spencer:
OK, this is where WAR loses me: #stlcards Yadier Molina ranks No. 118
in MLB with 1.6 wins. Should be up with Harper, Trout, Donaldson.
keithlaw:
@LyleMSpencer he's hitting .281/.320/.366. What kind of wins produced total
should that add up to?
Lyle Spencer:
@keithlaw I'd say 86-48 and 7-7 (Cards record when he doesn't catch) adds up
to a heckuva lot more wins than 1.8.
keithlaw:
@LyleMSpencer I asked you for a specific number. "More" isn't the answer. How
much more?
LyleMSpencer:
@keithlaw OK, here's my number: 8.5. Makes more sense to me than 1.8.
keithlaw:
@LyleMSpencer All you've really done so far is cited this:
https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/personal-incredulity
大意 Lyle Spencer覺得摸小弟對球隊的貢獻值應該應該跟鱒魚與美國BAM-BAM
同個水準。WAR只給1.6太低了~
Keith Law回他:那你覺得.281/.320/.366的打者該值多少WAR?結果對方
說應該比1.8的WAR高。
Keith Law有點嗆的回說:"更多"不是確切數字,到底是多多少!Lyle
Spencer最後回應:8.5,8.5至少比1.8更貼近他的想法
結論:大家不要自卑!領薪水的老外腦袋也是有燒壞的時候
***
本人宣布,再也不關注baseball版。不過好像也沒人在意 lol