[討論] 拿破崙 metacritic 媒體評價出爐

作者: sherlockedxx ((Targaryen))   2023-11-15 19:12:44
評論來源:https://reurl.cc/dmj5XV
優點:
衛報: 100分
Phoenix is the key to it all: a performance as robust as the glass of burgundy
he knocks back: preening, brooding, seething and triumphing.
瓦昆是一切的關鍵,表演方式如同一口喝下的勃根地酒般強勁,自滿得意,憂愁滿面,沉
潛怒火,再凱旋歸來。
帝國雜誌: 80分
Scott's take on Napoleon is distinctively deadpan: a funny, idiosyncratic clos
e-up of the man, rather than a broader, all-encompassing account.
雷利史考特對拿破崙的刻畫,有著他獨特的執導風格,帶點嚴肅卻不失幽默描寫拿破崙,
以貼近的角度而不是以宏觀的方式呈現這個角色。
BBC: 80分
It feels like a tantalising trailer for the longer and presumably richer and d
eeper film that is still to come.
整部電影像一道可口的前菜,預示著更豐富且有深度的下一部電影即將到來。
缺點:
Time Out: 60分
Ridley Scott delivers a spectacular but flavourless French history lesson.
雷利史考特拍出了一部壯闊卻索然無味的法國歷史課電影。
Variety: 50分
Dense without feeling rushed, then done without ever having really sprung to l
ife, Napoleon seems determined to cover a great deal of ground over its not-in
significant running time.
濃縮劇情卻不讓人覺得進展過快,但又少了真正賦予角色生命力的那種感覺,這部電影想
要在有限電影時長中,涵蓋太多太多東西。
以上是簡單翻譯一下,翻得不好請指正XD 謝謝
看評論有點涼掉,但又沒那麼涼的感覺QQ
作者: sherlockedxx ((Targaryen))   2023-11-15 20:22:00
看起來應該就是不上不下
作者: manfromuncle (Skyfall)   2023-11-15 22:13:00
花月殺手哪裡是糞片…明明很好看
作者: candbilly153 (Black·Muya·White)   2023-11-16 09:04:00
結論:等導演版

Links booklink

Contact Us: admin [ a t ] ucptt.com