討論中強調「QD球必須要出手」是著墨在規則「43.3 罰則」的規定，43.3.3的原文是「I f a free throw is not successful...」的情境下討論如果違例者是罰球員或其隊友時 、或如果違例者是罰球員的對手、或雙方違例時的處理。 原文If a free throw is not successful並未強調一定要「投籃不中」，如果根本無法 出手呢？我認為也是在「free throw is not successful」的範圍內。 一般在罰球時你會謹慎去投那顆球，如果在球出手前被嚇到或發現有干擾，第一時間你會 投出那顆球嗎？這不太合乎一般反應。 重新看了影片幾次，QD並沒有做假動作，他將球往上舉，並仔細瞄籃，**並未把球往下收 或有晃一下的動作**。 至於接獲裁判給球後五秒內需出手，我的肉眼看到的是張伯維在第五秒的時候踏進到他面 前來。 如果QD並未假動作違例、也未五秒違例，裁判並未判張伯維罰球干擾違例給予QD重新罰球 機會；而是判QD違例並取消該次罰球...... 這樣對嗎？ ※ 引述《asdfgh0920 (A醬)》之銘言： : 關於上半場QD被判罰球違規那個判例，一開始我也是在LIVE文忿忿不平 : 所以跑去查了FIBA相關規範 : 以下是2014 fiba的規定： : 43.2.3. The free-throw shooter shall: : 關於罰球員的規範 : : o Take a position behind the free-throw line and inside the : semi-circle. : o Use any method to shoot a free throw in such a way that the ball enters : the basket from above or the ball touches the ring. : o Release the ball within 5 seconds after it is placed at his disposal by : the official. : 從裁判手中接過球後，應在五秒內投射離手 : o Not touch the free-throw line or enter the restricted area until the ball : has entered the basket or has touched the ring. : o Not fake a free throw. : 不得做罰球假動作 : 43.2.4. The players in the free-throw rebound places shall be entitled to : occupy alternating positions in these spaces, which are considered : to be 1 m in depth . : During the free throws these players shall not: : o Occupy free-throw rebound places to which they are not entitled. : o Enter the restricted area, the neutral zone or leave the free-throw reboun d : place until the ball has left the hand(s) of the free-throw shooter. : o Distract the free-throw shooter by their actions. : 搶籃板球時，不得以任何動作干擾主罰球員 : 43.2.5. Players not in the free-throw rebound places shall remain behind the : free-throw line extended and behind the 3-point field goal line unti l : the free throw ends. : 43.2.6. During a free throw(s) to be followed by another set(s) of free thro ws : or by a throw-in, all players shall remain behind the free-throw lin e : extended and behind the 3-point field goal line. : An infraction of Art. 43.2.3, 43.2.4, 43.2.5 and 43.2.6 is a violation. : 違反規則43.2.3條、43.2.4條、43.2.5條、43.2.6條，均屬於違規 : 43.3. Penalty : 罰則 : 43.3.1. If a free throw is successful and the violation(s) is committed by t he : free-throw shooter, the point, if made, shall not count. : 如果罰球中籃，但是罰球員違規的情形，則球進分數不算 : Any other player's violation which occurs immediately before, at : approximately the same time as, or after the violation committed by : the free-throw shooter shall be disregarded. : 如果罰球員違規，則在之前、同時或是之後的其他球員違規均不追究 : The ball shall be awarded to the opponents for a throw-in at the : free-throw line extended unless there is a further free throw(s) or : possession penalty to be administered. : 43.3.2. If a free throw is successful and the violation(s) is committed by a ny : player(s) other than the free-throw shooter: : o The point, if made, shall count. : o The violation(s) shall be disregarded. : 如果罰球中籃，而其他球員違規時：中籃有效，且不追究違例 : In case of the last or only free throw, the ball shall be awarded to : the opponents for a throw-in at any place at the endline. : 43.3.3. If a free throw is not successful and the violation is committed by: : o A free-throw shooter or his team-mate on the last or only free throw, the : ball shall be awarded to the opponents for a throw-in at the free-throw li ne : extended unless that team is entitled to further possession. : o An opponent of the free-throw shooter, a substitute free throw shall be : awarded to the free-throw shooter. : 如果罰球未進，而罰球員的對手違例時，由罰球員重新罰球 : o Both teams, on the last or only free throw, a jump ball situation occurs. : 研究了規定後，我認為： : 富邦搶籃板球員進場過早干擾了QD的罰球，屬於罰球違規在先沒錯 : 但是QD還是要球投出完成罰球動作 : 之後如果罰球沒進，裁判才會吹判重新罰球 : QD因為沒有出手，裁判要判罰球假動作或是5秒違規都可以 : 根據43.3.1 如果罰球員違規，則在之前、同時或是之後的其他球員違規均不追究 : : 因此我認為這次吹判沒有問題，大家討論看看0.0