[文法] 被動式的時態

作者: jeff42713 (翁傑夫)   2018-08-29 20:57:01
大家好
想請問一題被動語態文法題
In Peckham yesterday a shop assistant
(1) was forced (force) to hand over ?500 after (2) being threatened
(threaten) by a man with a knife. The man escaped in a car which (3) had been
stolen (steal) earlier in the day.
The car (4) was later found (later find) in a car park where it (5) had been a
bandoned (abandon) by the thief. A man (6) has been arrested (arrest) in conne
ction with the robbery and (7) is still being question (still question) by the
police.
我想請問第7格為何不能使用
still have been questioned
謝謝~
作者: dunchee (---)   2018-08-29 21:24:00
最簡單的解釋是"have been questioned"的動作已經結束((question(動)不是持續性質的動詞--警方已經問完就是問完了-> 搶匪被問完了,就沒有一直繼續被問下去 )。而"still"是表達動作持續意思的副詞,兩者意思互相牴觸,所以這不是答案is still being question->questioned
作者: timmy999 (憤怒a阿宅)   2018-08-30 01:25:00
文意吧 他這邊不是說那個人已經被逮捕因為跟搶劫案有關他這邊的and應該是然後的意思吧
作者: wohtp (會喵喵叫的大叔)   2018-08-30 15:35:00
arrest做動詞用是逮捕不是監禁。所以being arrested是正在被抓,可能警察正把他壓在地上還在扭打沒上好手銬。
作者: jeff42713 (翁傑夫)   2018-09-02 15:22:00
了解 謝謝回覆

Links booklink

Contact Us: admin [ a t ] ucptt.com